What to do if you have a concern

When you have a concern, it can be difficult to work out whether to submit an appeal, a complaint or something else. Getting advice before you submit anything can save you time and lead to a quicker and more effective resolution.
 
 

General advice

  • Avoid using AI to help you write an appeal or complaint - it overcomplicates and lengthens submissions, can leads to vital details being lost or missed by the people considering your submission, and is likely to delay the University's response.
  • If your case is complex and you wish to include a large amount of evidence, you should also provide a 150-word summary that clearly states what outcome you want, your primary concerns and the evidence presented.
  • The outcome of an appeal or a complaint may be that your concerns are not upheld. When this happens, it is highly unlikely that submitting the same issues through another process will result in a different outcome. We reserve the right to refuse to review concerns which have already been considered via a different route.

If you have questions about appeals, please email appeals@napier.ac.uk.

If you have questions about complaints or other resolution options, please email complaints@napier.ac.uk.

You can also take independent advice from the Edinburgh Napier Students' Association (ENSA).

 
 

Advice for submitting appeals

Strictly time limited

You only have one week from when your results are published to submit an appeal against that decision.

Trimester 1 results are published around mid to late February, and Trimester 2 results are published in late June. Some students will receive outcomes following the summer reassessment period in early to mid-September and some will receive outcomes for Trimester 3 in October.

View the results dates and appeal deadlines on the Making an appeal page under 'Understanding the appeals process - when can appeals be submitted?'

Based on specific reasons

There are only two grounds you can base an appeal on: the University has not followed its own regulations or procedures OR there is a procedural error in the recording of the results.

1. There is evidence to indicate that the Programme Assessment Board or the Academic Committee of the Doctoral College has made a decision which is not consistent with the University regulations and/or procedures.

The above ground relates to situations where you believe that the board has not correctly applied their decision in line with the regulations.

2. There is evidence to indicate that there was an apparent error in the recording, transcription or reporting of assessment results, the delivery of their programme or the assessment process.

Examples of this ground include:

  • The identification of any errors with assessment results recorded.
  • Evidence that material covered in assessments was not covered in class.
  • Evidence that you may not have received adequate and appropriate supervision and support with their assessment, dissertation or project e.g. staff absence not adequately covered, key meetings missed and not rescheduled, conflicting or inconsistent information provided.

Steps to take

  • Check you are within the deadline
  • Check your concern is covered by one of the specific reasons or 'grounds' above
  • Talk to your programme leader or a module leader to check whether they can resolve the situation

If you have done all these things, please review the information on the Making an appeal page to help you submit an appeal.

 
 

Complaints and other resolution options

Due to the limited scope and timeframes associated with appeals, you may wish to consider the options outlined to you on our Making a complaint page instead.

While still subject to some limitations, these options are not subject to the narrow grounds which apply to appeals and allow time for more in-depth consideration. However, the advice on keeping the details clear and concise still applies.